The Struggle with Metrics and the Desperate Need for Outcomes ©

Just recall when you last visited your family doctor. Quite typically she or he looked first at some basic numbers even before physically examining you. They checked to see what your pulse was, they ascertained your height and weight, they listened to your breathing and checked your oxygenation level, they…well, you get the drift. There are some numerical metrics that are key to accessing someone’s health.
Recently, I engaged in separate conversations on the subject of metrics in the life of the church with two people whose insights I hold in high regard – Gil Rendle and Rev. Mike Ramsdell. While the content of this blog is my own, I have permission from both gentlemen to share some of their reflections. The title I have placed on this piece of writing is indicative of the subject I invite us to explore – “The Struggle with Metrics and the Desperate Need for Outcomes.”
Have you ever asked yourself why the Bible shares some numbers? Look at Mark chapter 6, verse 44 Those who had eaten the loaves numbered five thousand men.” Or take the second chapter of Acts as example, So those who welcomed his message were baptized, and that day about three thousand persons were added.” (Acts 2:41) And day by day the Lord added to their number those who were being saved.” (Acts 2:47) There is more, but I hope the point is made. Someone has remarked that each number represents a person for whom Christ died.
In our UMC clergy culture, we are virtually numbers/metrics phobic. Yet, the numbers (or metrics) tell a story that cannot safely be ignored. Here in Central Texas, we have always led with the narrative or story – often quoting Gil Rendle’s mantra that “the narrative will change before the metrics.” At the same time, we have struggled to understand how to hold pastors and churches accountable for their ministry in ways that are both faithful and fruitful.
Prior to COVID-19, we started with the narrative (always first and most important) and then looked at two metrics – average worship attendance (using a rolling average) and professions of faith/restored. In these COVID times, we restructured our metrics to go with

  1. Number of small groups for discipleship,
  2. Professions of faith/restored plus baptisms,
  3. Average worship attendance (in person + online = total).

While many clergy have been resistive to metrics (especially average worship attendance) being a factor in appointment making, ironically most want their next church to be bigger in average worship attendance. (Or as Mike Ramsdell puts it, “they want a church someone else grew.”) Of further significance, even though we (the Cabinet) have changed the metrics with the most important being the number of small groups for discipleship formation, many of our local church leaders have trouble “hearing” or processing the change. They are still stuck on average worship attendance as the only metric of importance.

Fairly repetitively, from both the left and right sides of the theological spectrum, almost vitriolic opinions are pronounced about how the wrong things are being measured. Some have advocated that the only thing worth measuring is love, justice and mercy. others have postulated (or is the correct word postured) that we must measure growth in discipleship or holiness or (fill in the blank).
In one sense, these critiques are on target and valuable feedback. A pointed and ultimately helpful response is to ask the person advocating for a different metric(s) to be specific and concrete as to how they would measure the desired outcome. In my experience, it is exceptionally rare for those critiquing metrics to actually have some specific system for evaluating outcomes. Gil Rendle’s trenchant comment (see below) is apropos “If you don’t want any metrics, then you don’t really care if you are going to live very long.”
Mike Ramsdell and I have shared a number of conversations about what we paid attention to as Senior Pastors (Mike at First Methodist Mansfield and myself as Senior Pastor at both Bethany UMC in Austin and University UMC in San Antonio). Our collective list ran to something in the neighborhood 10 to 12 items. Here is a sampling from our recent conversation…

  • First, compare this year to last year (make sure you include special big days as almost a separate category, i.e. what was Christmas Eve attendance this year compared to Christmas Eve attendance last year?)  If possible, look back at longer trends like the last 10 years.
  • How many people are engaged in small groups for spiritual formation, prayer, and Bible study?
  • How many giving units do you have – monthly and consistently? (Mike emphasized that this is absolutely critical; “there is no way to spin it.”)
  • Worship attendance – both in-person and online; Use a tight system of measuring online worship. (It is worth noting that the regular worship of God is an absolutely foundational component of discipleship; to paraphrase Wesley, disciples regularly worship God.)
  • Number of people engaged in hands on mission and ministry with those in need.
  • Number of mission projects the church is engaged in.
  • Number of participants in Confirmation class.
  • Number of participants in Vacation Bible School.
  • How many guests/visitors/first time people on Sunday morning? (This is exceptionally important to track.)
  • Track your major special offerings (i.e. Christmas and Easter mission giving and especially those going beyond the local church).
  • How much is giving is coming electronically vs in-person giving?

Mike was constantly saying, “the truth/facts are your friends.” They help you understand where you are and what we need to work on. Both of us experienced our congregants as wanting this information. They like knowing where things stand and, if there are issues, what are the plans to improve things. They want a realistic hope that the future of their church is going to be better. (They don’t want just platitudes; they want concrete plans.)
The dilemma we have experienced at the Conference level is that it is a struggle to get pastors to report two or three metrics, let alone 10 or 11. Some view reporting even just two items as a burden. While I fully recognize that any true reporting on discipleship metrics should involve at least 5 or 6 items, we as a Cabinet in consultation with the Core Team have kept the list to a minimum, in part to get compliance. Furthermore, extensive secular research highlights the important concept of focus and strongly indicates that the “list” of goals should not get beyond two or three. (see The Four Disciplines of Execution by McChesney, Covey, and Huling) The evidence in our “metric phobic” UMC is that many pastors report mission engagement with the poor and needy (a vitally important metric) in glowing terms, while worship attendance, professions of faith and number of disciples continued their accelerating decline. One of the ironies of the Congregational Vitality project related to the Four Focus Areas of the UMC, which Bishop Schol headed (and I was a part of the leadership team), resulted in congregations with a high vitality rating closing because they had declined to the point of no longer being viable.
In a recent conversation with Gil Rendle (the author of Doing the Math of Mission: Fruits, Faithfulness and Metrics as well as a retired Vice-President at the Texas Methodist Foundation in congregational and leadership vitality and prior to that a long-time leader with the Alban Institute, plus time spent as a United Methodist pastor in the Philadelphia area), Gil lamented the inability to help move people to connect doing the math of missions with outcomes reflecting biblical faithfulness and fruitfulness.
Our dialogue went something like this: (These are my typed notes during our conversation and not an exact transcript. They are used with his permission.)

Looking back on The Math of Mission what would you change? The primary lesson is that people don’t have outcomes! We lamented together our mutual inability to get people to look at and set concrete outcomes for ministry. In an attempt to do so with the CTC Cabinet, what we came up with was a glowing list of noble aspirations. Gil commented that in his experience this was normal but very frustrating and ultimately unhelpful.
What, if any, metrics would you stress or lift up before pastors and churches? Post-COVID, we don’t know yet what vitality looks like. The way in which people have engaged congregations has changed. Before 1950, Sunday School was the best metric. By the 1950s, that had reversed and worship attendance was the vital metric. We don’t know how people are going to want to engage post-COVID (we have to learn our way into this). An annual conference needs to be asking itself “Is this a congregation that is still alive?”
“The three metrics we have,” Gil commented, “are perfect for that. These are the metrics a cabinet can use…. They tell you if a place is dead or alive.”
Individual local churches need to ask a different question: What is the fundamental action you are going to make in the next two years and how would you measure that? Gil suggested a DS conversation with local church leadership – lay & clergy – that invites them to set significant outcomes tied to concrete metrics. “You tell us what is your desired outcome and how do you measure it and we’ll be glad to follow it with you.” (If our metrics aren’t the right ones, what metrics will help you get where you want to be?)
What would you say to those who are insistent that they don’t want any outcomes? “If you don’t want any metrics, then you don’t really care if you are going to live very long.” The one thing the pandemic has not changed is covenant accountability in our relationship(s) both to the Lord and to the Conference, as well as to each other! (The intensity in Gil’s voice could be heard over the phone.)
We have kept the list of items to report to a minimum do we need more? For the purposes of appointment making, you only need two or three basics. If you want to talk about development towards vitality, then go to a larger number that is more specific to that situation. Gil encouraged a conversation along the following lines, “At the next charge conference, your DS is going to ask you which three [of a longer list] are you as a pastor and congregation paying attention to?”
What advice do you have relative to building accountability in a system that is resistive to accountability? Part of the answer to that is to hand the work back to them; Our generic metrics (i.e. the metrics the CTC Cabinet has outlined: small groups for discipleship development, professions of faith & baptisms, and worship attendance both in person and online) are going to stay but if you’ll tell us what your metrics (as a congregation) are, we will follow those with you. Together, we might learn what the most useful new metrics are going to be post-COVID.”

Gil closed with a deeply reflective comment that cements both the importance of metrics and the struggle in tying those metrics to the truly vital issue of faithfulness and fruitfulness in outcomes. “If you are a pastor coming out of COVID, you are not returning to the same world.  How are you going to be different and live in this new world as a vital congregation? If you can’t in some way measure it, you haven’t really thought through your desired outcome.”
What is the outcome we need? It is no more and no less that then the conversion of the world and establishment of the Kingdom of God “on earth as it is in heaven.” How now do we set measurable proximate steps to faithful proximate outcomes that advance the kingdom of God? I remind myself and share with you the injunction of the Risen Christ moments before his ascension…

But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you; and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, in all Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth.” (Acts 1:8)


Previous Posts

romans 12-18 quote cropped.jpg
An Insightful Evening ©

On Thursday evening Nov. 4, I drove to Rockwall, Texas, and joined with a widely ecumenical small group to listen to a presentation by Ed Stetzer. For those of you who do not know of Ed, he is what I would term a moderate Southern Baptist. As his ...

for all the saints blog header graphic squished.png
In Celebration of a Saint ©

The call from a close friend came out of the blue last month. “Bishop, I’ve got some bad news. Billy has died.” Stunned, it took a moment to register.   On this, the week we celebrate All Saints Day (Nov.1), I pause to recognize a theological giant ...

retirement celebration front page banner.png
The Songs I Chose ©

I was recently asked about special songs or hymns I would like sung at my Oct. 24 Retirement Celebration at Arborlawn UMC in Fort Worth. My first thought was that this was an especially gracious invitation on the part of the organizers of that ...

investing in the wig ftnas banner graphic.png
Investing in the WIG – Forward to a New Spring ©

As I read through Dr. Timothy Tennent’s probing book For the Body (which I highly recommend), I came across the following sentence: “The church is God’s divine work built on the foundation of Christ.” (For the Body, p. 190) This high holy ...

romans 12-18 quote cropped.jpg
A Plea for Peace ©

As I sat down to write this blog post, news started coming in of an active shooter at Mansfield Timberview High School. The Conference staff is joining with people of goodwill to pray for all those involved and that a peace-filled resolution to what...

aaction logo with stregthening witness tagline and ctc logo blog width 800.png
A Plan of AACtion! © (A Guest Blog with Dr. Clifton Howard)

At a crucial turning point in Jesus’ teaching ministry, our Lord and Master directs his followers, “a new commandment I give you, love one another just as I have loved you, you also are to love one another.” (John 13:34)   Following the teachings of...

comfort o comfort remember and recommit blog banner.png
A Time to Remember and Recommit ©

Like most Americans, I can remember precisely where I was on the morning of September 11, 2001. I had been the Senior Pastor of University UMC in San Antonio for just five and a half weeks. That morning, I was preparing for a staff meeting when ...

wig narratives banner.png
WIG Sightings and Celebrations ©

Psalm 100 peeled its beauty in my heart and mind on Sunday.    Make a joyful noise to the Lord, all the earth. 2     Worship the Lord with gladness;     come into his presence with singing. 3 Know that the Lord is God.     It is he that made us, and...

called to christian help.png
Sharing Christian Help in Times of Disaster ©

These are indeed unprecedented times. The gravity of the season in which we find ourselves can be devastating – and is for many. It only takes a quick scan of your newsfeed to become overwhelmed by the images of hospitals setting up COVID care ...

ctc guidance delta variant banner grx.png
Responding to the Delta Variant Surge ©

Dear friends, our uncompromising mission remains to “make disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world.” With this holy calling comes the obligation to be disciples of Jesus Christ. The Apostle Paul reminds us... “Do nothing from ...

witness in a confused world banner grx slightly squished.png
Forward Towards a New Spring: A Different Church for a Different World Part III ©

The Forward Towards a New Spring series of blogs began on April 19 with “A Different World Struggling to Be Born.” The second post in the series was published on April 30 under the title “The Search for a New Center.” The following is the third ...

rebuilding the foundation.png
Rebuilding the Foundation: “Real Methodism” ©

As I have indicated through numerous addresses, including my most recent episcopal address, I believe we are in a time and period where we need to (and are engaged in) rebuilding the foundations of Methodism. One of the key architects in this work ...

be guided by faith not driven by fear covid-19 banner.png
COVID-19 Response & Guidelines Update ©

With excellent work by our Conference Communications team under Vance Morton’s leadership, we have posted an update on the Central Texas Conference’s COVID-19 Response, Guidelines and Information section of our conference website. Having recently ...

welcome to church banner.jpg
Reflections on Hospitality and Communion ©

In the heat of July, our family vacation finds us back in West Virginia (our future retirement home near family living in the D.C and Boston areas). As churches and Christians across the country slowly open back up, we have found ourselves ...

way way back to the future  title slide.png
Way, Way Back to the Future – Envisioning a New Spring (Part 3) ©

On June 21, at the 2021 annual meeting of the Central Texas Conference (CTC), I delivered what I believe will be my last episcopal address to the CTC – “Way, Way Back to the Future: Envisioning a New Spring,” I have been sharing a printed version ...

way way back to the future  title slide.png
Way, Way Back to the Future - Envisioning a New Spring (Pt 2) ©

On June 21, at our recently concluded annual meeting of the Central Texas Conference (CTC), I delivered what I believe will be my last episcopal address to the CTC – “Way, Way Back to the Future: Envisioning a New Spring,” I am sharing a printed ...

absolute basics of the wesleyan way banner grx.png
A Strong Recommendation: The Absolute Basics of the Wesleyan Way ©

I recently finished reading Phil Tallon and Justus Hunter’s new book The Absolute Basics of the Wesleyan Way. My zeal for this marvelous little book causes me to pause and write this blog post and a direct email to the pastors and lay leaders of the...

way way back to the future  title slide.png
Way, Way Back to the Future Part I ©

On June 21, at our recently concluded annual meeting of the Central Texas Conference (CTC), I delivered what I believe will be my last episcopal address to the CTC – “Way, Way Back to the Future: Envisioning a New Spring,” I am sharing a printed ...

be guided by faith not driven by fear covid-19 banner.png
It’s Time to Reopen – Guided by Faith Not Driven by Fear ©

Today, we put the finishing touches on what I hope will be my final video on the COVID-19 pandemic (see video below). Throughout the pandemic, we have remained committed to the understanding that we are to be “Guided by Faith, Not Driven by Fear.”  ...

bishop saenz to be coverage bishop blog banner.png
Bishop Ruben Saenz Coming to Central Texas in January ©

By now, many of you have already read that Bishop Ruben Saenz will assume episcopal responsibility for the Central Texas Conference on January 1, 2022. His selection as the coverage bishop for Central Texas represents the culmination of a careful ...

spirit on the move.jpg
A Pentecost Follow Up ©

Jesus had made a promise. “…I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Advocate, [helper] to be with you forever. This is the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it neither sees him nor knows him. You know him, because ...

what does this mean banner.png
Pentecost Reflections: What Does This Mean? ©

I am tired of a spiritually atrophied Unitarian United Methodism which acts as if the Holy Spirit is not real. This past Sunday, I had the privilege of preaching at First United Methodist Church in Grapevine. With their Sr. Pastor out recovering ...

bishop to retire front page banner cropped.png
Vocational Retirement ©

Through the struggle of the church to be the church in a time of pandemic, in the chaos of our time in the life of America and the diverging future of the United Methodist Church, I have experienced the Lord leading us into a new spring. While that ...

let the little children come 2.png
Let the Children Come ©

With Mother’s Day right around the corner, I can help but thank God for the mothers by which I’m blessed – my mother, the mother I am married to, the mother we raised, and the mother we cherish as a daughter-in-law. When my mother would play catch ...

the search for a new center.png
Forward to a New Spring: A Different Church for a Different World Part II ©

The Search for a New Center About four years ago, when visiting one of our Central Texas Conference Churches, I sat in the back row. At the close of the service, a young lady sitting next to me walked up and professed her faith in Christ for the ...

end racism banner.png
A More Perfect Union – A Guest Blog ©

In light of the jury verdict in the Derek Chauvin murder case, we are collectively feeling our way forward to a new future much like someone with impaired sight might grapple into a new building. Here in the Central Texas Conference, we are ...

end racism banner.png
With Justice for All ©

The words are emblazoned on the founding document of the nascent American independence movement. They form the aspirational template for what we as a nation seek to be when at our best. We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men [and ...

different world stuggling to be born banner.jpg
Forward Towards a New Spring: A Different Church for a Different World Part I ©

A Different World Struggling to Be Born A heartwarming event took place at the close of the 11 a.m. traditional worship on Sunday, April 11, Michael and Sue Beaton joined Arborlawn United Methodist Church. Their story is a tale of the WIG – the ...

luke 24_5-6 for easter banner.png
On the Edge of Eternity ©

Moderators Note: Bishop Lowry's video message to the conference for Easter is available for viewing or downloading at the end of this post. The day opens simply, while teetering on the edge of eternity. The Evangelist Luke records the story.  “But on...

your king is coming.jpg
Journey to the Cross ©

Moderators Note: Bishop Lowry's video message to the conference for Palm Sunday and Holy Week is available for viewing or downloading at the end of this post. As we begin the week that we Christians call “Holy,” I invite you to step back with me into...

isaiah 58-6.jpg
A Green Response to Injustice ©

Imagine the following true story and place yourself in it.   You are kidnapped sometime in your teenage years. Hauled in chains to a different country, you are sent to work in hard and dangerous labor – slave labor. Much of your time is spent alone,...

map-reading-with-compass cropped.jpg
A Map for Emerging from the Pandemic ©

  As we move through Lent, we are all struggling with issues of re-opening. The WIG remains our mission with an emphasis in discipleship formation through small group ministry, outreach to the community/mission field, and professions of ...

new church for a new world front page banner.png
Building a Post-Pandemic Church ©

Last week, I had the privilege of sharing with many of you in a webinar featuring Dr. Thom Rainer and produced by the Texas Conference UMC. Dr. Rainer is the head of a highly respected Christian “think-tank” and coaching platform called Church ...

winter storm response cropped.png
Recovery, Renewal and Recommitment ©

The Sunday after the great winter storm of 2021, many members of the Cabinet and Conference staff leadership team dispersed across the Central Texas Conference to visit various churches and communities damaged by the cold, snow, bursting pipes and ...

disaster relief efforts.png
The Central Texas Conference Offering Disaster Relief ©

As I write this blog (Friday afternoon, Feb. 19), we are working as a Conference Team with District Superintendents (DS) and members of the District Discipleship Teams to provide assistance and disaster relief across the Central Texas Conference. ...

being-the-church cropped and colored 2.jpg
The Church Being the Church ©

Moderators Note: As the temperatures finally begin to climb above freezing in Texas and frozen pipes begin to thaw, pipes that burst during the deep freeze will begin to leak and could cause damage quickly. Authorities suggest that you locate the ...

a message for lent from bishop lowry 2021 cropped.jpg
A Message for Lent 2021

In this time of chaos and confusion caused by COVID-19 and, most recently, by the dangerous winter weather conditions throughout Texas that have left many without power, heat and/or water, many find it difficult to know how to best move, much less ...

ac19 wig combo logo.jpg
Revised WIG Reporting ©

At our 2020 Annual Conference meeting, we passed an initiative called Forward to a New Spring. In most aspects, this initiative is nothing new at all. Our mission still remains our Wildly Important Goal (WIG) – “to make disciples of Jesus Christ for...

forward to a new spring banner grx.png
On the Move to a New Spring ©

In C. S. Lewis’ epic tale, The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe , one of the first creatures the children encounter is Mr. Beaver. Beaver has great wisdom and insight even in a time of the land frozen and in the grip of the White Witch. Quite soon ...

end racism graphic stacked colors inverted fat banner.png
Ending Racism In Our Lifetime – Moving From Awareness to Action © (A Guest Blog)

In the turmoil surrounding us and the uncertainty of the church’s future (both coming out of the COVID-19 pandemic and a possible General Conference vote on the Protocol), I do not want us to lose sight of our need and commitment to work on ending ...

a different kind of walk banner.png
A Different Kind of Walk ©

As I did four years ago (and four year prior to that, and…), I ask the Christians of the Central Texas Conference of the United Methodist Church to pray for our newly inaugurated President and Vice-President, our Senators and Representatives in the ...

protestors break barricade banner.jpg
A Statement of the Storming of the U.S. Capitol ©

Please see below for Bishop Lowry's message regarding today's mob protests at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C.   With you, I have watched today’s mob assault on the U.S. Capitol with horror and revulsion. We are a country built on the rule of ...

2021 grx banner size.jpg
Entering a New Year ©

Bishop Lowry states it succinctly and well when he opens his New Year’s message to the conference with “Thank God 2020 is over!” With our sigh of relief that we have begun a New Year, it is good to remember that we have hope and joy in the coming ...

A Birth Announcement: God with Us! ©

“Joy to the world, the Lord is come!”  May this great birth announcement ring out in homes, be twittered and tweeted in our communities, blogged about on websites, sent in our emails, and zoomed around our nation and world! Click on the video below ...

issac watts and joy to the world music.png
Joy to the World ©

In my life, Christmas isn’t really Christmas until we sing two hymns as a part of Christmas Eve worship – “Silent Night” and “Joy to the World.”  The words of “Joy to the World” sweep me away. “Joy to the world! The Lord is come; Let earth receive ...

standing on the promises grx.jpg
Standing on the Promises ©

The first United Methodist Church to which I was appointed as a pastor on my own was St. Paul’s UMC in Kerrville, Texas. Just out of seminary, and not even married a year, I was excited and full of ideas. Practical reality landed on my desk in week ...

the spirit of the lord god is upon me.jpg
The Spirit of the Lord ©

During my senior year in High School, I took a choral class to finish out my requirements for graduation. I recall spending most of the time sitting in the back, laughing and goofing off but then as Christmas came near something unusual happened. ...